![]() |
Aileen Quinn and Ann Reinking Annie (1982) |
Anika Noni Rose, Beyoncé Knowles and Jennifer Hudson Dreamgirls (2006) |
Renée Zellweger Chicago (2002) |
![]() |
Idris Elba Cats (2019) |
![]() |
Marilyn Monroe Gentlemen Prefer Blondes (1953) |
the top, campy woman whose Lorelei would have come off as obnoxious on screen. However, Monroe's taut, bubbly and sensuous portrayal is a match made in heaven for the screen, especially when you add in Jane Russell's sharp witted and down-to-earth portrayal of Dorothy Shaw. If Miss Channing had reprised her role the film, in my opinion, would be nowhere near as successful and "Diamonds Are A Girl's Best Friend" would not be the iconic number it is today. Channing was also fine with Monroe taking on her part (Streisand starring in the Hello, Dolly! movie is another story...) In a similar situation was with the 2007 film adaptation of Hairspray where John Travolta played cooped up housewife Edna Turnblad, a role originated by Harvey Fierstein on stage (which he won a Tony for.) Many people, including Fierstein, were upset that he was not cast in the role of Edna, but I am glad Fierstein wasn't. He's a wonderful man and fantastic Edna, but his Edna would not have fit with Adam Shankman's (who directed and choreographed Hairspray) vision for the film. The screenplay by Leslie Dixon toned down a majority of the campiness (I think this was an extremely wise move, but that is an entirely different topic for another post) which included taking out all of the 4th wall breaking jokes, several of which were jokes about Edna being played by a man. Therefore, Fierstein's signature deep, gravelly voice would be out of place in the movie. This is another instance where had the stage actor reprised their role on film the movie would have suffered because
![]() |
John Travolta Hairspray (2007) |
![]() |
Diana Ross and Michael Jackson The Wiz (1978) |